Average Customer Review:
( 8 customer reviews )
Write an online review and share your thoughts with other customers.
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
14 of 16 found the following review helpful:
Great coverage on all aspects of infosecMar 19, 2002
By Ben Rothke
"Author of 'Computer Security: 20 Things Every Employee Should Know'"
Web Security, Privacy & Commerce, 2nd Edition by Simson Garfinkel with Gene Spafford O'Reilly & Associates 2002 ISBN: 0596000456 There are two basic reasons why a book comes out in a second edition: either the author needs the cash or the book needs to be updated. When the first edition of Web Security, Privacy & Commerce came out in 1997, it was titled Web Security & Commerce. Not only has the title changed, but Web security, privacy, and commerce have changed radically in the last five years. The nature of the change and the pace at which it occurs is a large part of the difficulty within information security. Imagine a heart surgeon going on an extended vacation in 1997 and coming back in 2002. Although his surgical technique may be a bit rusty, there is no reason to think that he could not start practicing medicine again right away. However, if you were to take a contemporary information security professional from 1997 and place him in the 2002 workplace, he would be horribly outdated. Technologies that did not exist in 1997, or even 2000, are now ubiquitous, and technologies that were considered cutting edge only a few years ago are now archaic. With that, the update to Web Security, Privacy & Commerce is indeed warranted and welcomed. A glance at the table of contents reveals coverage of nearly every core aspect within Web security. The book provides a comprehensive and impartial look at the technologies and approaches that both management and systems administrators can employ to ensure the security of their networks and systems. The author's impartiality is revealed in chapter 15, which describes several telephone scanner utilities; Garfinkel is the creator of one of the utilities, but makes sure to list the competition (and even has nice things to say about them). Simson Garfinkel and Gene Spafford are veterans in the computer security world. Garfinkel is the author of several highly acclaimed books, and Spafford is a professor of computer science at Purdue University. Their succinct writing style allows them to cover a huge amount of information in a little over 700 pages. The book is divided into four sections: Web technology, privacy and security for users, Web server security, and security for content providers. Part one goes into details about the security foundations of the networks and the Internet. Topics include SSL/TLS, PKI, digital signatures, and biometrics. These seven chapters give the reader a good overview of the essence of information security. Part 2, "Privacy and Security for Users," is quite different from other security books. Whereas other books detail the problems with privacy on the Internet, this book does a good job of showing users various strategies for keeping their personal information private. Garfinkel shows how the real threats to personal privacy are not so much cookies and log files; rather the end-users very own readiness to provide Web and e-commerce sites with their personal information. Part 3, "Web Server Security," details how service providers and systems administrators can lock down and secure their systems. The authors provide details on topics such as host security, server access methods, and secure CGI/API programming. Part 4, "Security for Content Providers," is quite interesting, as many content providers and ISPs forget that the onus of security and privacy to a large degree falls on them. This section includes details on how these providers can use various techniques, from filters to PICS and more, to ensure their users' privacy. The fact that Web Security, Privacy & Commerce, 2nd Edition, is nearly twice the size of the first edition is indicative of the fact that security has changed radically since 1997. Whether you run a Web site or are concerned about security for your PC at home, Web Security, Privacy & Commerce is a must read.
12 of 14 found the following review helpful:
Outstanding: Clear and to the pointDec 16, 2001
By Abe Usher
"information security nut"
I work as a computer security analyst for a major consulting firm. Garfinkel's book is head and shoulders above anything else out there. In particular, his handling of the tension between security policy and privacy policy is particularly well written. I highly recommend this book to anyone that wants to develop a detailed understanding of the significant issues that affect doing business on the web.
16 of 20 found the following review helpful:
In a word, disappointing.May 15, 2002
Apart from paid reviewers I can't see anyone with any actual knowledge of security rating this book 5 stars. It is not as clear and concise as it should be, and the technical knowledge is freely available at securityfocus.com and other sites. A better job could have been done with security and privacy policies. More effort should have been put forth in providing common sense (implementable) solutions or best practices instead of re-hashing material that other books have already done a better job presenting. I normally enjoy O'reilly books but like the first edition, this book is a disappointment.
3 of 3 found the following review helpful:
Good bookNov 10, 2002
By Ra Tera
"crablegs"
Good read, but primarily as an introductory primer. General info and comprehensive, with good discussion and resources. But to really get into the nuts and bolts of this subject, you will need to find other books. Somewhat esoteric at times and frustrating.
1 of 1 found the following review helpful:
Totally outdated - OverweigthedMar 28, 2012
By PenName This book shouldn't be sold anymore.
This edition is from 2002...10 years old on a topic evolving every week.
Its like making open-heart surgery with a 19th century book.
Second problem is that this book is way too big with topic that has nothing to see with security.
For example you have a PHP topic which start by introducing the language basics.
Conclusion : Don't buy.
See all 8 customer reviews on Amazon.com
|