Average Customer Review:
( 7 customer reviews )
Write an online review and share your thoughts with other customers.
Most Helpful Customer Reviews
9 of 10 found the following review helpful:
Disappointing and OverpricedJun 02, 2002
By Marco De Vivo
"Mr. TCP/IP"
I can hardly believe this book is endorsed by RSA. Actually I purchased the book because of this endorsement. Alas, I'll be more careful in the future. For sure. Sorry to say this, but you can learn more on wireless security in the Readers' Digest than in this book. The issues are treated in a very naive way. Just 'generic outlines' (remember this book is 'worth' [money]).
For instance, Spread Spectrum is discussed in about ONE and a half pages. WEP in just two half pages. WAP explanation is a mess (lousy mess).Even worse is chapter 10, 'real examples'. Several bad explained naive 'case studies', with no match between the figures and the 'related' discussions. Interested in Bluetooth security issues?. Well there is HALF page covering Bluetooth, not an inch more. Believe me, you can find worthier information, in a 5 minutes search through Internet. Lost my money ...
3 of 3 found the following review helpful:
Without equalJun 14, 2002
By Mike Schiffman I have done alot of research into 802.11b security and this book is a GREAT addition to my collection. Great examples, good overview and nice flow. I've seen Pollino speak and this book is just like his presenations -- informative and authoritative. I fully recommend it to anyone interested in wireless security.
Not enough depth, just an overview of technologies, protocolMar 25, 2005
By rnidamar This book begins with the history of wireless communications and wireless networks. It then talks about the various wireless security threats. It follows it by describing various wireless security protocols and cryptography, which does not have any depth. All the protocols discussed can be understood by novice. He never talks about the current or future trends of these technologies. He describes about how to secure wireless devices which is really not necessary or so important. Then moving on to various voice technologies, he gives an good overview of these technologies, but never talks in detail about any one technology. If we want to learn more about these technologies we need to read another book.Same holds true for wireless data networks and security protocols. He talks about many technologies, but very little about each one of them.Not enough focus on even 1 technology, just the ABC's. We need to read another book for more details. Never talks about the current or future trends really. He also describes some applications of wireless security protocols in the real world, which might a little helpful to feel as to how they might be used.
Overall, read this book only to know about all the technologies available and security standards at a very superficial level. Only breadth and no depth. But the book can be understood by novice,as it is presented in lucid form. Cetainly not for some one wants to really know more or dig in deep about these issues.
Both comprehensive and readableOct 18, 2002
When I wanted to expand my skills into wireless security, I bought almost every wireless book available. This is, by far, the best of the lot. If you already have a basic understanding of protocols and crypto, this book will be well worth the time.
To the pointJun 06, 2002
By System Administrator The book was concise and too the point on wireless security topics. It did not waste my time with non security related topics.
See all 7 customer reviews on Amazon.com
|